← The 4 story monsters

2 of 4 · 5 parts · bones + soul

Ghost

The master question

What does my audience believe about themselves right now, and what will they believe when this is over?

An ordinary-looking woman sits down in front of a camera. Over the next minute, a team of makeup artists goes to work on her: foundation, eyeliner, lipstick, then the hair, then the lights. And then, when a real person can be made no more beautiful, a computer takes over. Her neck is stretched, her eyes are widened, her jaw is slimmed, until the face on the screen is a billboard, and the billboard goes up over a bus stop. The line underneath reads, ‘No wonder our perception of beauty is distorted.’

That was Dove, in 2006, and there isn’t a plot anywhere in it. Nobody goes on a journey. Nothing is overcome. And yet a whole story lands, the kind that can change how a woman feels the next time she looks in the mirror. That story monster is what I call a Ghost.

A Ghost is a story with a soul but no body. It has the bones, a protagonist, a goal and an antagonist, and it has the soul, a flaw and a lesson. What it doesn’t have is the body: no inciting incident, no midpoint, no crisis, no climax, no resolution. Nothing happens, in the plotted sense.

A ghost is a soul that has lost its body.

It has all the feeling of a transformation, with none of the events that would normally carry it.

So how can a story work when nothing happens in it? A Skeleton, you’ll remember, works because the audience infers the missing parts and builds the whole story themselves. A Ghost asks both less of them than that and more.

Less

The soul is already on the page: the flaw and the lesson, the deepest parts, are handed over directly.

More

The one part that’s missing, the body, is the part the audience has already lived.

Think about who Dove was talking to.

Tap each question for the answer

She doesn’t need Dove to stage a journey towards the belief that she isn’t beautiful, because she already believes it. All that’s left to do is turn it.

That’s the whole trick of a Ghost. The body’s only job was ever to earn the transformation. In brand content, you often don’t have to earn it, because your audience arrives already carrying it. Give them a real flaw they recognise as their own, and the lesson that overturns it, and their own life supplies everything in between.

The same trick works with a single person at the centre. Under Armour ran an ad in which a child’s voice reads out a ballet rejection letter, ‘you have the wrong body for ballet’, while the dancer Misty Copeland warms up and then dances anyway, flawlessly. There’s no plot. The letter names the flaw, ‘you don’t belong here’, and her body disproves it in front of you.

Building one is simple.

The flaw

The limiting belief your audience carries. For Dove it was ‘I’m not beautiful.’

The lesson

The belief you want them holding when it’s over. Dove’s was ‘you already are.’

The enemy

What keeps the old belief in place. For Dove, the whole machinery of beauty.

And then comes the part that makes it a Ghost: don’t build a plot. Don’t stage the journey. Deliver the turn directly, the proof, the reframe, the single moment the old belief breaks, and trust your audience to bring the rest.

Then test what you’ve made. Can your audience see themselves as the protagonist, is the flaw genuinely theirs? Is it a real flaw, an actual belief being disproved, and not just a pleasant sentiment? Is there a true before and after, a belief that changes? And does it move them, because a lesson only ever gets through to us when it makes us feel something.

Last, the test that tells a Ghost from its bigger cousin: could you strip out every event and still have it work? If it falls apart without the plot, you’ve made a Frankenstein instead.

Always’ ‘Like a Girl’ sits right on that line. A director asks teenagers and grown men to run and throw and fight ‘like a girl’, and they flail and giggle; then he asks young girls the same, and they do it with everything they have. There’s the faint shape of a body in there, the experiment, the contrast, the moment an older girl is asked to try again and this time runs like she means it. But strip all of that out and the story still stands: the flaw is that ‘like a girl’ means weak, the lesson is that it doesn’t, and every woman watching has already lived the plot.

Reach for a Ghost when you want to change what your audience believes about themselves, not just what they know. And a Ghost can carry any belief you like. When Nike launched ‘Just Do It’ in 1988, its first ad opened not on an athlete but on an 80-year-old man named Walt Stack, running across the Golden Gate Bridge on one of his 17-mile morning runs. Same shape, different flaw. The protagonist is you, the goal is to become someone who moves, and the enemy is the small voice that says exercise is for other people. The flaw is ‘I can’t.’ The lesson is ‘if he can, you can.’

Sport England did the same for a nation of women who had all but written themselves off. ‘This Girl Can’ was real women, not models, running and boxing and swimming and dancing, red-faced and out of breath and jiggling, over lines like ‘I jiggle therefore I am.’ No story, no single hero, just a wall of proof aimed at one flaw, the fear of being watched and judged, and the lesson underneath it: do it anyway.

For your brand

Get the flaw and the lesson right, and you won’t need a single event to carry them from one to the other.

Before you write a single line, ask

What does my audience believe about themselves right now, and what will they believe when this is over?

Give your Ghost as many of these traits as possible.

The checklist

0 / 9

Want me to build you one?

I’m offering five marketing managers a full story-driven campaign for free.

Claim your founding spot →